Zeda, the company behind Avis and Budget, expects its full-year earnings per share to fall by 16% to 20%. In a trading statement for the year to September, it said headline earnings per share should land between 288.6c and 303.1c, down from 360.8c the year before. And the reason has less to do with renting cars than with selling them.
Why cheaper new cars hurt a rental company
A big part of Zeda's business involves selling off its rental cars after about a year through its Car Sales division. But new-car prices have been coming down: established manufacturers have seen 18 to 20 months of price deflation, and competitively priced Chinese and other Asian brands have added to the pressure. That narrowed the gap between a new car and the one-year-old cars Zeda sells, pushing down what those used cars are worth and adding competition from nearly new cars, particularly from established brands.
The second half of the year coincided with Zeda's defleet cycle, the scheduled point at which it takes cars out of its rental fleet. Rather than flood the market, it delayed selling some cars and bought fewer new ones. As a result, it sold about 14% fewer used cars in the second half, roughly a month's worth of sales. It did shift more of its sales to retail buyers, up from 32% to 35%, which partly cushioned the hit to margins.
Where the earnings went
Holding onto rental cars for longer came at a cost. The longer lifecycle pushed up depreciation, and Zeda also lowered what it expects its cars to be worth to reflect the weaker used-car market. Together, those account for substantially all of the decline in operating profit, and operating margins were about 200 basis points, or two percentage points, lower. As Zeda admitted, the pressure on used-car prices hit harder than expected, so the improvement it had hoped for didn't materialise.
The rest of the business held up. Revenue was flat at R10.7 billion, as growth in leasing, car rental and the rest of Africa made up for weaker car sales, and net finance costs fell despite five interest-rate increases across its markets. Zeda says leasing and its Greater Africa business should drive future growth, with full results due on or about 24 November. Cheaper new cars might be great news for South African motorists, but for a company that makes money selling them a year later, they're a real headache.