For the past decade, Europe's big banks have been packing up and leaving Africa. Barclays, BNP Paribas and Société Générale have all scaled back their African operations, and this year, HSBC wrapped up its exit from South Africa after more than three decades here. But speaking to Bloomberg this week, Investec South Africa's CEO, Cumesh Moodliar, said conversations with European bankers at the recent IMF meetings revealed a renewed interest in the continent. He met a number of German banks in Bangkok, and as he put it, the European banks are also looking at the continent with interest. So why did they leave, and what's changed?
Why Europe's banks packed up
A lot of it came down to rules and returns. After the 2008 financial crisis, European regulators weren't all that keen on banks taking big risks anymore. Capital requirements got stricter, the cost of checking customers ran high, and returns at African subsidiaries looked weak by comparison. Fitch says the retreat was particularly pronounced among French banks, with Crédit Agricole, Société Générale and BNP Paribas selling or already out of most of their African operations.
And we didn't exactly make things easier for them either. Weakening currencies, high inflation, government debt troubles and bad loans all ate into profits once those profits were converted back into euros or pounds. On top of that, most African banking markets are fairly shallow, with South Africa and Morocco the exceptions. Bank balance sheets lean heavily on government bonds, lending mostly goes to big corporates and state-owned companies, and insurance is underdeveloped in many markets. That left fewer chances to sell clients wealth, insurance and investment products, the kind of cross-selling that made the business worth it elsewhere.
While these European banks headed back north, someone else filled the gap. Banks from South Africa, Nigeria and Morocco expanded across the continent, alongside local banks and mobile-money operators. Take HSBC, which never built a retail branch network here, focusing instead on big corporates, trade finance and private banking. When it left, its corporate banking business went to FirstRand's RMB and its equities business to Absa. But Fitch warns that while this has opened up opportunities for African banks, they're also taking on more risk, as trade finance and international banking shift onto local players with patchier access to foreign currency.
Why South Africa is among the front doors
So why the renewed interest? African banking revenues topped $100 billion last year, according to McKinsey, and African banks earned a return on equity of 17%, well above the global average of 10%. The Americans are already onto it. JPMorgan has opened offices in Nairobi and Abidjan, and in October won approval in principle from Nigeria's central bank to set up a merchant bank there. Bank of America plans to grow its corporate and investment banking across Africa, while Citigroup is scaling up trade finance. According to Moodliar, European lenders are taking their cue from them. And South Africa, with regulation that matches Europe's and deep capital markets, is among the key winners if global lenders return.
But don't expect a wave of new European bank branches anytime soon. Fitch expects much of this to happen behind the scenes, with European banks partnering with African banks on trade finance and sharing lending risks. That lets them make money in Africa without committing as much capital or carrying the compliance burden on their own. Moodliar sees it the same way: the old approach was all bricks and mortar, but now there's an opportunity for South African and African banks to partner with international ones. So while Europe's banks spent the better part of a decade leaving Africa, their way back in might well be through the very banks that took their place.