Companies

Coronation says SA's weak economy is leaving households too stretched to save

Coronation's earnings fell and clients pulled R13.8 billion, as slow growth and two-pot withdrawals squeeze what South Africans can invest.

Coronation says SA's weak economy is leaving households too stretched to save

Coronation says it's finding outstanding opportunities, but South Africans don't have much left over to invest. The fund manager's headline earnings per share fell 14% to 406.8c for the year to September, while fund management earnings per share fell 9% to 413.7c. Revenue was flat at R4.29 billion, and operating costs rose but stayed below inflation.

Smaller outflows, but still outflows

Clients pulled a net R13.8 billion from Coronation over the year, though that was a big improvement on the year before. Those outflows came to 1.8% of its R774 billion in average assets, compared with 5.4% the previous year. Total assets ended the year at R750 billion, down 1%, even though average assets grew 10%, which Coronation says reflects strong growth followed by a consolidation of those gains. It declared a final dividend of 210c, taking the total for the year to 413c, down 9%.

Why the economy is the bigger problem

The bigger problem is the economy. With growth of less than 1% a year on average for more than a decade, households are struggling to save, and that puts added strain on the whole savings and investment industry. Two-pot withdrawals have made it worse: about R57 billion was withdrawn across the industry in the first year after the system launched in September 2024. Coronation says a sustained improvement in flows will depend on stronger economic growth, and CEO Anton Pillay told News24 the economy needs to grow by more than 3% a year. As he put it, without economic growth, you can't expect the local savings industry to grow.

Some of Coronation's funds have also lagged the market. It held fewer of the tech and resource shares driving the indices, with tech making up almost 40% of the S&P 500 and resources about 30% of the JSE All-Share. Pillay told News24 that was a deliberate risk-management choice.

Despite all this, Coronation remains optimistic. It says precious metal shares here look fully priced, but valuations elsewhere in the market are extremely attractive, and it sees more long-term potential in quality businesses using AI than in the picks-and-shovels companies that benefited first. As it put it, investors who are prepared to be patient will make excellent returns for many years to come. The question is how many South Africans have the spare cash to be that patient.

Join our free daily newsletter

Business news, before your coffee's gone cold.

The markets, the money and the deals that actually matter — in your inbox every weekday at 6:00am. A free, five-minute read.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.