Ninety One saw clients withdraw a net £4.2 billion, about R71 billion, from its funds in the six months to September. Founder and CEO Hendrik du Toit called the flows disappointing, and said they ran contrary to what the asset manager had expected at the start of the period. Founded in South Africa in 1991 and listed in London and Johannesburg, it's one of the country's largest asset managers.
Where the money left
Ninety One did attract money into Asian and emerging market equities, but that was outweighed by outflows from global and South African equities and multi-asset strategies. Clients pulled money out in the UK, Africa, the Americas and Asia Pacific, with Europe the only region where more came in than went out. Du Toit put it down to two things: weak investment performance in two important categories, and slower-than-expected inflows in areas where performance has been good, like emerging markets, commodities and resources.
He was candid about the first one. As he told News24, the main global indices were pretty hard to beat because of the single focus on the AI trade. And in South Africa, he told News24, the team just made mistakes and hadn't picked the right stocks for a while, which he says is now fixed, although it takes time to restore a track record.
Bigger, but still losing clients
The odd part is that despite those withdrawals, the total amount of money Ninety One manages grew 19% over the past year to £181.4 billion, in a year when it also took over Sanlam's actively managed funds, with Sanlam moving R400 billion across in exchange for a 12% stake. Adjusted operating profit rose 19% too, to £117.8 million, with the operating margin improving to 32.5%, and the interim dividend is up 5%. Basic earnings per share, though, fell 8%. Yet the share price fell more than 7% to R42.29 in mid-morning trade on Monday.
Du Toit says the market remains intensely competitive, with clients focused on costs and continually raising the bar. He also told News24 that AI companies are coming for everything, and Ninety One is building its own central research platform so anyone in the firm can model its data with AI. Investors, it seems, care more about where the money's heading than about how much is already there.