Big story Companies

SPAR's store owners lost patience with the board, and now a major shareholder has too

M&G, which holds almost 15% of SPAR, wants five new directors, after years of costly mistakes and a fight with the store owners who run its shops.

SPAR's store owners lost patience with the board, and now a major shareholder has too

Most shareholders are pretty quiet. They buy the shares, collect the dividends and, if they're unhappy, they simply sell. But this year, South African investors have started speaking up, and SPAR is now right in the middle of it. On Monday, the retailer said M&G Investment Managers, which holds about 14.69% of its shares, has formally demanded a shareholders' meeting to elect five new non-executive directors. Two of the names will sound familiar: turnaround specialist Phil Roux, who turned down a seat on SPAR's board on Friday, and former CEO Angelo Swartz.

How Poland, Switzerland and SAP cost SPAR

To understand why patience has run out, you have to go back a few years. SPAR spent an absolute fortune trying to make it overseas. In Poland, it had to pump R2.7 billion into the struggling business to recapitalise it, before selling it for just R185 million. Exiting Switzerland then left it with a cash outflow of about R683 million, including roughly R250 million paid to the Swiss Competition Commission. Then, in 2023, a new SAP supply chain system at its largest KwaZulu-Natal distribution centre went disastrously wrong, leaving store owners struggling to get goods for their shelves. SPAR is now facing litigation over that failure. And by the time it reported its annual results last December, a R158 million profit the year before had turned into a whopping R5.1 billion loss.

That's where the store owners come in. Most retailers tell their store owners what to stock and how to run things, but SPAR's stores operate independently, with much more freedom. Those owners belong to the SPAR Guild, which has spent much of this year in conflict with SPAR over its executives and leadership. They backed CEO Angelo Swartz, a retailer himself who led the exits from Switzerland and Poland, until he resigned suddenly in February. The share price took its biggest fall of the year that month. In May, the Guild called for chairman Mike Bosman to resign over concerns about management failures, and on 17 August, he and deputy chair Shirley Zinn did.

In September, the Guild backed Phil Roux to become chairman. SPAR eventually offered him a board seat, but on Friday it said he had declined, with his undisclosed conditions not met, and the shares closed 4.4% lower. The new chair is Lwazi Koyana, the board's longest-serving member, who has been there since 2019, through the costly exits and the SAP failure. Now M&G wants shareholders to vote both Roux and Swartz onto the board, alongside Anton Wentzel, George Skoutellas and Omnichand Lalbahadur.

Mr Price, Shoprite and a year of louder investors

SPAR isn't the only company facing louder investors this year. In January, Benguela Global Fund Managers called on Mr Price to halt its R9.66 billion purchase of European retailer NKD, arguing the deal was overvalued and carried an unacceptable risk profile. It asked for a shareholder vote, but the JSE rejected the request, and NKD joined Mr Price in March anyway. At Shoprite this month, in the first AGM season where shareholder votes on pay are binding, 46.19% of ordinary shares voted against the CEO's pay policy. It still passed, helped by deferred shares that give Wiese about 41% of Shoprite's voting rights.

So what happens next? Under the Companies Act, holders of at least 10% of the voting rights can force a shareholders' meeting, and SPAR says it'll issue a notice within 10 business days, with the meeting expected within 25 business days after that. In fairness, the board says it respects that right, will put every nominee through the same fit-and-proper checks, and has invited M&G to meet its nominations committee. But with its share price down almost 75% over five years, it's clear that SPAR's shareholders and store owners have had enough.

Join our free daily newsletter

Business news, before your coffee's gone cold.

The markets, the money and the deals that actually matter — in your inbox every weekday at 6:00am. A free, five-minute read.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.