SPAR's efforts to sort out its leadership have hit another setback. On Thursday, the retailer confirmed Lwazi Koyana, its acting chairman since 17 August and its longest-serving director, as chairman, and appointed former Massmart CEO Grant Pattison as an independent non-executive director from 25 February 2027. Pattison spent 16 years at Massmart, where he was also President of Walmart in South Africa. At the time, SPAR said an offer had also gone to Phil Roux, and that his response was still outstanding. But on Friday morning, it said the turnaround expert had confirmed in writing that he would not accept. SPAR's share price dropped as much as 5% that morning, before recovering sharply after the announcement.
Why Roux mattered
Roux is well known for his turnaround work at Pioneer Foods and Nampak. Under his leadership, Pioneer's share price rose from R53 in 2012 to a peak of R204 in 2015, paving the way for its acquisition by PepsiCo in 2020, and Nampak's has more than tripled since May 2023. He also had the backing of the SPAR Guild, which represents the franchised retailers, with a leaked September letter calling his appointment an important opportunity for alignment. Roux told News24 he had in fact replied that he would only accept with conditions, and that SPAR's announcement was incorrect, though he didn't say what the conditions were. He told Moneyweb his decision was not because of the challenge, which he would have embraced.
A board under pressure
That alignment matters. SPAR's previous chairman, Mike Bosman, and deputy chair, Shirley Zinn, resigned with immediate effect on 17 August, citing conflict with the Guild. The share price has fallen about 75% over the past five years, after costly expansions into Switzerland and Poland, both since exited, and a failed SAP software implementation at its largest distribution centre that drove independent retailers to buy from other suppliers. SPAR says the appointments of Koyana and Pattison are unaffected, and that it will keep looking for directors with the right skills and experience. The shares closed Friday down about 4%.
With franchisees, the board and shareholders all needing to pull in the same direction, getting everyone on the same page is proving easier said than done.